Wistia vs Vimeo for Video Content Marketing

Video marketing is growing faster and faster every year.

Creating video content used to be a secondary role for digital marketers.

Commercials or expensive video ad placements were big undertakings that were a lower overall priority.

Not only do we now watch more video than ever but including video content actually increases organic traffic from SERP’s by 157%

Businesses that aren’t producing regular video content are losing traffic and becoming less relevant to their audiences.

Youtube used to be the obvious “go to” software for video hosting and video marketing in general before companies like Wistia and Vimeo grew their focus on video marketing and hosting.

But more and more marketers are moving away from Youtube and toward other video software platforms whose goals align more closely with their own.

Youtube, for example, is a free platform that makes money when users watch more and more videos, so they place more and more ads on your videos which take attention away from your brand and your messaging.

When considering Youtube alternatives for video marketing, two companies are obvious candidates and in this article we’ll explore them head to head: Wistia vs Vimeo.

Should You Choose Wistia or Vimeo?

Here are some of the most important features to look at when comparing differences between Wistia vs Vimeo for video marketing.

Pricing

Vimeo and Wistia both have free entry level plans and increase their features and video storage on their paid plans.

Wistia’s paid plan, Wistia Pro, starts at $80 per month when billed annually. It includes 10 free videos and each additional video is 25 cents/month. Wistia Pro includes all of the features of the Wistia Advanced plan except Wistia Channels.

Wistia pricing plans

Vimeo’s video marketing plans start at $50 (Business) and $75 (Premium) per month billed annually. Their business and premium plans offer 5TB and 7TB of storage respectively.

Vimeo pricing plans

Video Player Customization

Both video players have similar player customization options. They allow you to choose your video player color, thumbnails, logos, links, and calls-to-action. Custom CTAs are only available in Vimeo’s Business & Premium plans whereas custom CTAs are standard on all Wistia plans.

Video customization makes custom branding possible so that your player matches your company and colors. In this category of Wistia vs Vimeo, they’re pretty equal.

video player customization on Wistia

Lead Generation

Vimeo’s lead generation tools are not available in Plus or Pro, but are standard in Business and Premium plans. These tools allow you to push viewers toward certain web pages (via the CTA) or capture a lead if you make your video gated (with their email capture screens).

Wistia’s lead generation tools come with every plan, including the free plan (although you only get 3 videos on the free plan). CTA’s, and lead capture functions similar to Vimeo.

Lead generation and email capture on Vimeo

Video Analytics

Wistia video analytics beats Vimeo analytics on this category. Wistia is more designed for marketers who are obsessed with analytics whereas Vimeo is traditionally known for filmmakers.

Wistia comes with beautiful heatmaps that show exactly what part of your videos are watched, re-watched, and watched again. This is a big win for content marketers who want to know how engaging their videos are and where their audience is falling off.

Wistia video analytics

Vimeo analytics features are comparable to the rest of Wistia’s features. Their analytics tools include plays, social views, engagement rate, impressions etc.

Note: we built an audience profiling tool to make sure your videos are correctly addressing your audience. The Custom Avatar tool is the exact method we use for pinpointing our audience. Get it here.

SEO Data

The Wistia player injects metadata into your webpage’s header, without any manual work. This give you SEO credit for your video content and keywords. Videos can help with SEO ranking so this is an important distinction for the Wistia video player.

In my research I didn’t see anything indicating that Vimeo injects SEO data onto your webpage to optimize for search which is a missed opportunity for video marketing.

Video SEO

Do Wistia & Vimeo Have Video Player Ads?

Nope. Neither Vimeo nor Wistia show ads on your video player. Capture the full attention of your audience and control their customer journey without distracting ads that pull them away from your website.

Software Integrations

Wistia and Vimeo both integrate with tons of marketing, productivity, and analytics platforms like Hubspot, Mailchimp, Infusionsoft, Marketo, Zendesk, Pardot, Google Analytics etc.

Video Player Size & Load Time

Wistia’s video player size steals first place for marketers.  They’ve gone above and beyond the video player size standard to offer the smaller player size with the fastest load times.

wistia video player size compared to Vimeo video player size

Wistia’s video player size is 108KB and Vimeo’s video player size is 150KB.  If you want to compare that to Youtube’s video player size at 505KB, Vimeo and Wistia will both load faster but Wistia’s is the fastest.

For marketers, this means faster page load and faster video player load which may reduce bounce rates and increase engagement.

Publish to Social

Vimeo allows publishing videos to Youtube, Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn whereas Wistia only publishes to LinkedIn and Facebook as of the publishing of this article.

Vimeo publish to social feature

Live Streaming

Vimeo does allow native live streaming to multiple social media platforms but only with a Premium account. Wistia does not have live streaming.

A/B Testing

Wistia includes A/B testing with all of their plans.  You can test 2 different videos to see what thumbnail, colors, and videos perform better in a given placement in order to optimize your user experience.

Vimeo plans do not come with A/B testing.

Customer Support

Wistia customers rave about Wistia’s customer support team that is very responsive and knowledgeable. Vimeo’s support team is reportedly very small so that customers lean more on their own ability to troubleshoot product issues.

Playlists & Channels

Video playlists, or channels as Wistia calls them, are great tools for episodic content, short courses, or for any series of videos that you want to guide users along a playlist of videos without distraction.

Vimeo has embeddable playlists for all 4 of their paid subscriptions. Wistia calls their playlists “channels” and makes them fully available on their Advanced Plan. The Pro Plan comes with 1 non-embeddable channel to link to from your website.

Wistia channels

Review & Collaboration Tools

Vimeo wins in this video marketing category.

Their collaboration tools have a beautiful interface with automatic version history saving. All notes are time coded and located right in the video player. Users can be assigned a role, such as client, team member, or freelancer and they can be given access to certain videos based on their role.

Wistia also has collaboration and review features, but their video review tool is more basic with fewer bells and whistles.

Vimeo collaboration tool

Bottom Line: Wistia vs. Vimeo

At the end of the day, it depends on what you want to do with your videos.

Wistia is built for businesses. Every inch of the Wistia platform was imagined and designed for marketing small and large businesses.

Existing features and, presumably, all future product rollouts will be about video marketing, content marketing, conversion optimization, and traffic acquisition.

If you’re a business looking for a hot video marketing tool backed by a company that is obsessed with video marketing for businesses, then Wistia is probably for you.

Vimeo is first and foremost a video platform for film producers. It has long been the go-to option for independent films, short films, and more. In the recent past, they’ve been rolling out video marketing tools similar to those of Wistia, but video marketing for businesses isn’t the backbone of the company.

Vimeo does offer many similar features to Wistia and offers plans that start at a lower price point, so if you’re cost conscious and happy with the tool suite available with one of Vimeo’s four plans, than Vimeo will likely be a great choice for you.

About the author

About Josh

Josh is an Eau Claire home towner and graduate of UWEC. He loves collaboratively building marketing campaigns with grit and grace. After biking home from work he loves to play guitar on his front porch and head downtown with his wife Nicole and son Rowen.

Tell us what you think

Share your thoughts here in the comments! Have a burning question or feedback about the topic? Let’s keep the conversation going.